NHL10 September 29, 2009
Posted by Cesar in games.Tags: EA Sports, games, NHL, reviews
add a comment
So based in the previous post:
- Is NHL10 a better game than NHL09? YES;
- Did NHL10 get a better review? NO.
The game looks slightly better, it plays awesome, the addition of board play is really cool and I love the first-person fighting. It’s better. Period. And the reviews agree. They just don’t score properly.
See you space cowboys…
Game reviewers are going nuts September 29, 2009
Posted by Cesar in games, gaming me.Tags: games, reviews, sequels, Tony Hawk
1 comment so far
There is something very wrong with game reviews. I used to talk a lot about this with a friend in Brazil. The best games don’t get the best scores and that’s just crazy. Now, I am not saying I don’t agree with the reviewers. That is normal. What is insane is when the review directly states the game is better but the grade is still lower. That usually happens with sequels. We see it all the time with sports franchises. The one to blame is the so called innovation factor.
Sure, if a game breaks paradigms, does something completely original, it deserves credit. Obviously the sequel will not be all that refreshing, right? But is it weird to give it a lower grade. Just think about the utility of the grade: the buyer, curious, wants information on what skating game to purchase. He goes to gamerankings.com, looks at the averages and then goes to his favorite store to get the title. He gets out with Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 2 under his belt. The game is so old there was a Dreamcast version of it. Now if you actually read the reviews for Tony Hawk’s Proving Ground, the main complaint that pulls the grades down is lack of originality. The game itself is better. Want another example? Soul Calibur. The original, for the Dreamcast, is still the one with the best score.
I guess no one want’s to see the old classics surpassed by new ones that just steal the tricks from their older brothers. And I love to see Ocarina of Time at the top of the rankings. The reviews as they are make sense at the exact time they were written: the best game of 1995 is probably not the best of 2009, even if the grade is higher. It is logical, even though in a weird way. And for direct sequels, it is useful to know if the new one is worth buying, considering you already have the old one. I, for one, would like to see review sites at least include a separate space for a timeless game grade. A score that simply tells you which one is the best.
See you space cowboys…
Hello world! September 27, 2009
Posted by Cesar in gaming me.Tags: foreigner, games, sports, St. John's
1 comment so far
Hello world! Well, this is my first post but since I already spent a lot of time on the blog’s layout (I hope everyone likes it), I’m a bit tired and uninspired so I am going to make this a meta-post and talk about me and blogging.
The best description I can give of myself in one word is gamer. I like any kind of game. Minesweeper, poker, football (and don’t tell me it’s soccer), Gears of War, basketball, Metal Gear Solid, Tetris, Formula 1, Hockey. If they are keeping score, I’m interested. Except for baseball, but I will save this for another post.
So I hope to write about all that and other crazy s$#! that goes on in my mind. That and my jorney from Brazil to Canada, the next step in my game programming career. From a Summer of 35 degrees Celsius to a Winter of -25. Talk about a big change, eh?
But all in time, so that’s it so far. See you space cowboys…
gaming me 